The controversy over the recruitment of Haredim is tearing Israeli society apart. On the one hand - a cry for equality of burden, a feeling that an entire public is avoiding the heavy price and dedication of protecting Jews. On the other - a deep concern for the fate of the Torah world, a fear that Jewish identity will be erased.
This debate, painful and divisive as it is, hides a much more fundamental question: Why can't Israel win its wars?
Parashat Toldot offers a revolutionary answer through the story of Isaac, Rebecca, Jacob, and Esau. "The voice is the voice of Jacob, and the hands are the hands of Esau" – the principle that determines whether we win or fail. Rebecca understands that Jacob must go out into the field and fight, but only when his field is "a field which the Lord has blessed' – full of identity, purpose, and moral clarity. When Jacob is cut off from his voice, from faith in the righteousness of the path, even the strongest hands fail.
Want more news, videos and stories? Join the Haredim 10 WhatsApp channel >>
Rabbi Jacobson explains that the IDF's problem is not a shortage of 'manpower' but a crisis in the 'human spirit'. An army that is afraid of winning, that apologizes for its existence, that prefers 'conflict management' to resolution - cannot succeed. No matter how many soldiers are recruited.
The lesson also examines the opposite question: Does Haredi education foster true Jewish pride or merely fear of the outside world?
