Divorce is a complex process, but when children are involved, the legal and emotional challenges become even more significant.
Parents often find themselves in a legal battle over their right to raise their children, when the other parent does not function as a responsible parent or the relationship between the couple becomes strained to the point of harming the children's best interests.
In a case that recently came to the office of Attorney Lilach Hirsch-Opir, The mother sought to reduce the time the father spent with their children, claiming that his behavior was irresponsible and endangered their physical and mental well-being. She claimed that the father had difficulty providing the children with a stable environment, was not fulfilling his parental obligations, and was sometimes extremely careless when they were under his care.
Among other things, the mother claimed that the children returned from his custody confused and agitated, after being exposed to inappropriate behaviors on his part, including leaving them alone for long periods of time, leaving them without adequate supervision, and failing to take care of their health and nutrition.
The mother expressed genuine concern that the father did not recognize their emotional needs, and therefore requested that meetings with him take place in a controlled and gradual manner, until he demonstrated proper parental ability.
The father, on the other hand, denied the allegations, claiming that this was an attempt to distance him from his children and reduce his involvement in their lives. He said that he provides them with a warm and loving home, and there is no justification for imposing restrictions on contact with him.
In cases of this type, when there is a deep disagreement between the parents regarding the ability of one of them to fulfill his parental responsibilities, the court is required to appoint a social worker (SW) to conduct a thorough examination of the situation. The SW's role is to meet with both parents, talk to the children, and visit the living environment of each parent in order to assess the parental framework that the children are receiving.
In this specific case, after several meetings and an examination of the family dynamics, the social worker submitted a detailed report to the court, in which she recommended adjustments to the parenting arrangements. The report stated that the best interests of the children require the establishment of a clear and stable framework, and that at this stage, the father's time of stay should be limited and parental guidance should be incorporated in order to improve his ability to fulfill his parental role.
The court accepted the recommendations of the social worker and determined graduated stay times with partial supervision, with the father committing to participating in a parenting training program.
The decision emphasized the need to create a regular routine for children, with the aim of ensuring their emotional stability and a healthy and balanced relationship with both parents.
Beyond this specific case, there is a general trend of change in the legal system's perception of parenting after divorce. In the past, the term "custody" was entrenched in legal discourse and caused unnecessary battles between parents, with each party trying to achieve the status of "custodial parent."
Following the ruling of the Honorable Justice Shaul Shohat (Amash 13008-02-21) and the amendment of the Family Court Procedure Regulations in 2020, the current trend is to switch to using the term "joint parental responsibility", focusing on residence times rather than class definitions between the parents.
The courts today make it clear that there is no longer room for lengthy discussions around the question of "who is the custodial parent?", but rather that the focus should be on dividing visitation time and dividing parental responsibility. This avoids exhausting legal battles and ensures that the children do not become a tool in the fight between the parents.
Legal decisions regarding parental responsibility are not limited to residence arrangements alone, but affect a variety of significant aspects of the lives of children and parents. One of the key issues is the change of residence of the children. When one parent requests to move to a distant place of residence or abroad, this may affect the relationship with the other parent. The courts carefully examine such requests, taking into account the best interests of the child and maintaining contact with both parents.
Research indicates that joint custody arrangements, when implemented with communication and coordination between parents, contribute to the emotional and developmental well-being of children. Conversely, lack of coordination and ongoing conflict between parents can cause confusion, instability, and damage to children's sense of security.
How does the Lilach Hirsch-Opir Law Firm assist with custody (parental responsibility) issues?
Custody battles are not just a matter of dividing up time – they determine the future of children. Our office works to ensure that the process is conducted from a professional perspective focused on the best interests of the child, while preserving the rights of the parents.
If you are facing a dispute regarding parental responsibility and visitation rights, contact the law firm of Lilach Hirsch-Opir without delay. Proper and timely legal treatment can prevent long-term damage and preserve your rights as parents.
Contact us today for an initial consultation 0526055560
English 
Hebrew